On March 30, two days after the Mad Ants' 2022-23 season ended, York signed a two-way contract with the Indiana Pacers. This marked the second call-up of his career and the second straight season he signed a two-way to finish the NBA season with the Pacers.
On April 5, York made his season debut for the Pacers in a loss to the New York Knicks. In his first ever game as a Pacer at Gainbridge Fieldhouse, York went 3-of-6 from three point range and finished with a career-high 9 points.
York would play in two more games with the Pacers, scoring eight against Detroit and then adding seven points in a season ending win over the playoff bound New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden.